84 Main Street, New Paltz, NY 12561
Phone (845) 256-9289 Fax (845) 256-1354

Register with us

CAPTCHA Image
Daily Specials
Other Offers

Menu

Print
On Premise Catering
Buffet Options
Choose from one of these great options or have us customize a package for your next party. Birthday, Graduation, Holiday, Corporate Event, Any Party, Any Occasion! Just scroll over the packages for information and pricing.
$0.00
Standard Appetizer Buffet .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$0.00
Deluxe Appetizer Buffet .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$0.00
Standard Buffet .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$0.00
Deluxe Buffet .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
Appetizer Options
Appetizer options for your next party. Scroll over items for descriptions.
$0.00
Buffalo Wings .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$0.00
Chicken Tenders .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$0.00
Mozzarella Sticks .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$0.00
Potato Boats .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$0.00
Italian Meatballs .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$0.00
Swedish Meatballs .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$0.00
Beef Satay .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$0.00
Chicken Satay .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$0.00
Chips and Salsa .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$0.00
Nachos with Chili and Cheese .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$0.00
Stuffed Mushrooms .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$0.00
Vegetable Crudite .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$0.00
Fruit and Cheese Platter .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$0.00
Fried Calamari .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$0.00
Jalapeno Poppers .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$0.00
Breaded Ravioli .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$0.00
Vegetable Spring Rolls .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$0.00
Cheeseburger Sliders .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$0.00
Chicken Sliders .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$0.00
Pulled Pork Slammers .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$0.00
Chicken and Spinach Dip in a Bread Bowl .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$0.00
Irish Nachos .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
Salad Options
Salad options for your next party. Scroll over items for descriptions.
$0.00
Caesar Salad .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$0.00
Chef Salad .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$0.00
Garden Salad .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$0.00
Greek Salad .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$0.00
Tomato Mozzarella Salad .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
Side Options
Side options for your next party. Scroll over items for descriptions.
$0.00
French Fries .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$0.00
Mashed Potatoes .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$0.00
Macaroni and Cheese .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$0.00
Rice .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$0.00
Dinner Rolls .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$0.00
Pasta .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
Entree Options
Entree options for your next party. Scroll over items for descriptions.
$0.00
BBQ St. Louis Ribs .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$0.00
Corned Beef and Cabbage .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$0.00
Shepherds Pie .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$0.00
Fish and Chips .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$0.00
Chicken Marsala .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$0.00
Chicken Francaise .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$0.00
Lemon Chicken .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$0.00
Sausage and Peppers .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$0.00
Sliced London Broil .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$0.00
Chicken Parmesan .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$0.00
Penne A La Vodka .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$0.00
Baked Ziti .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$0.00
Fettucine Alfredo .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$0.00
Veggie Bake .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$0.00
Four Cheese Pasta Bake .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
Food Menu
Appetizers
Served all day and night, 11am-4am
$6.95
Chicken Claws .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$7.50
Chicken and Spinach Dip .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$6.95
Cuddy's Sliders .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$4.50
French Fries .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$11.95
Heart Attack Sampler .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$6.95
Irish Egg Rolls .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$8.50
Irish Nachos .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$5.95
Mozzarella Sticks .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$9.50
Nachos .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$5.50
Onion Rings .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$6.50
Potato Boats .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$6.95
Pulled Pork Slammers .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$7.50
Quesadilla .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$9.95
St. Louis Spare Ribs .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$7.95
Veggie Platter .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$5.50
Waffle Fries .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
World of Wings
Over 20 Flavors of Wings! Ranging from Hot to Sweet
$6.95
Red Hot BBQ .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$6.95
Gold Fever .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$6.95
Inferno .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$6.95
3 Alarm .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$6.95
Volcanic .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$6.95
Smoldering .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$6.95
Honey Buffalo .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$6.95
Sweet Heat BBQ .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$6.95
Sweet Thai Chili .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$6.95
Wasabi Dijon .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$6.95
Cajun Spice .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$6.95
Raspberry Chipotle .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$6.95
Bourbon .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$6.95
Jamaican Jerk .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$6.95
Teriyaki .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$6.95
General Tzo .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$6.95
Gold Rush .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$6.95
Garlic .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$6.95
Garlic Parmesan .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$6.95
Honey BBQ .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$6.95
Coconut Peanut .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$0.00
Mix and Match Any Two Flavors! .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
Soups
Delicious Home Made Soups and Chili
$4.95
Irish Potato Soup .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$4.95
Soup of the Day .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$4.95
French Onion .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$5.95
911 Chili .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
Salads
Fresh Salads Made with Local Vegetables
$6.50
The Big Salad .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$5.95
Caesar Salad .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$8.95
Buffalo Chicken Salad .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$9.95
Taco Salad .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$8.95
Asian Mandarin Salad .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$0.00
Dressing Choices .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
Burger Board
All Burgers are Served on an Egg Twist Roll with Lettuce, Tomato, and Pickle Along with your Choice of: French Fries, Baked Potato, or a Side Salad. (Substitute Waffle Fries of Onion Rings for $1.00 Extra).
$7.95
Build-A-Burger .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$7.95
Turkey Burger .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$7.50
Veggie Burger .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$0.50
Toppings List (First Topping Included) .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
Sandwiches
All Sandwiches are Served with Your Choice of French Fries, Baked Potato, or a Side Salad. (Substitute Waffle Fries or Onion Rings for $1.00 Extra).
$6.95
BBQ Beast .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$7.95
Bourbon Chicken Sandwich .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$8.50
Buffalo Chicken Wrap .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$7.95
Chicken Club .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$8.95
Cajun Roast Beef Melt .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$7.95
Chicken Ranchero Wrap .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$7.95
Classic BLT .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$8.95
Corned Beef Reuben .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$7.95
Grilled Cheese .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$8.95
Hot Open Roast Beef .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$8.95
Hot Open Turkey .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$9.95
McGillicuddy's Mess .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$9.95
McGillicuddy's Steak Sandwich .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$8.95
Pastrami Reuben .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$8.95
Philly Cheese Steak .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$6.50
Soup or Salad and a Half .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$6.95
The Traditional .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$8.95
The Triple Lindy .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
Cuddy's Favorites
Traditional McGillicuddy's Favorites!
$10.95
Shepherd's Pie .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$8.95
Fish and Chips .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
Fajitas
Served with Shredded Cheddar Jack Cheese, Salsa, Sour Cream, and Lettuce
$10.95
Chicken Fajita .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$13.95
Salmon Fajita .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$13.95
Shrimp Fajita .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$11.95
Steak Fajita .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$9.95
Veggie Fajita .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$13.95
The Two Way Fajita .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
Paninis
All Paninis are Served with your Choice of French Fries, Baked Potato, or a Side Salad. (Substitute Waffle Fries or Onion Rings for $1.00 Extra).
$8.95
Chicken Godfather Panini .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$9.95
Prime Rib Panini .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$8.95
Turkey Club Panini .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$7.95
Veggie Panini .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
Pastabilities
Served with a Side Salad
$14.95
Cajun Shrimp Broccoli Alfredo .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$13.95
Four Cheese Pasta Bake .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$11.95
Garden Pasta .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$13.95
Penne A La Vodka .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
Off The Grill
Served with a Side Salad, Vegetables, and Your Choice of French Fries, Baked Potato, or Rice. (Substitute Waffle Fries or Onion Rings for $1.00)
$17.95
BBQ St. Louis Spare Ribs .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$14.95
Breaded Chicken Parm .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$17.95
Chicken and Rib Combo .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$19.95
New York Sirloin .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$15.95
Pan Blackened Salmon .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
Kids Menu
Available for all children 12 and under. All kids meals served in a boat and come with a toy from the McGillicuddy's Treasure Chest! All Kids Meals Served with your choice of Fresh Fruit Salad or French Fries
$4.95
Kid Burger .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$4.95
Chicken Little .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$4.50
Say Cheese! .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$4.95
Wing Ding .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$3.95
Kid Pasta .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$3.95
Hot Diggity Dog .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
Drink Menu
Fish Bowl Drinks
All Fish Bowl Drinks Made with Arizona Iced Tea Products.
$15.00
Cuddy's Iced Tea .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$15.00
Cuddy's Margarita .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$15.00
The Coco Mango .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$15.00
The Electric Lemonade .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$15.00
The Hurricane .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$15.00
The John Daly .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$0.00
The Birthday Bowl .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
Bottled Beer Menu
A List of Our Available Bottled Beers. Prices Subject to Change.
$4.00
Amstel Light .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$4.00
Blue Moon .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$4.00
Blue Point Blueberry Ale .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$4.00
Brooklyn EIPA .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$4.00
Brooklyn Lager .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$4.00
Brooklyn Pennant Ale '55 .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$4.00
Brooklyn Pilsner .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$3.00
Bud Light .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$3.00
Budweiser .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$4.00
Cooperstown Benchwarmer Porter .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$3.00
Coors Light .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$4.00
Corona .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$4.00
Harp Lager .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$4.00
Heineken .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$4.00
Heineken Light .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$4.00
Keegan's Ale Old Capital Lager .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$4.00
Kona Longboard Lager .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$4.00
Kona Fire Rock Pale Ale .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$4.00
Magic Hat #9 .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$4.50
Magner's Irish Cider .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$4.00
McSorley's Ale .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$3.00
Michelob Ultra .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$4.50
Negra Modelo .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$4.00
Newcastle Brown Ale .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$4.00
Peak Organic Amber Ale .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$4.00
Sierra Nevada Pale Ale .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$4.00
Smithwick's Irish Ale .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$4.00
Southampton Double White Ale .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$4.00
Yuengling Lager .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
Draft Beer Menu
A List of Our Available Drafts. Prices Subject to Change.
$3.50
Bud Light .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$5.00
Brooklyn Brown Ale .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$5.00
Guinness .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$5.00
Hoegaarden .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$3.50
Miller Lite .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$5.00
Red Hook Long Hammer IPA .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$5.00
Samuel Adams Seasonal Draft .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$5.00
Stella Artois .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
Wine List
A List of Our Available Wines. Prices Subject to Change.
$5.00
Foxhorn White Zinfindel .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$5.00
Foxhorn Chardonnay .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$5.00
Foxhorn Pinot Grigio .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$5.00
Foxhorn Merlot .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$5.00
Foxhorn Cabernet Sauvignon .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$6.00
Berringer White Zinfindel .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$6.00
Berringer Chardonnay .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$6.00
Yellowtail Shiraz .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
$6.00
Blackstone Merlot .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
 

Company

Restaurant

Connect

McGillicudy's
Copyright 2012 
Cool Life Systems